Discounting "unicorns" and other nonsense, which only those trying to close down the thread are throwing in; what is called insane by some is genuinely what others would like. Yes it is a wish list, though others might call it market research for which one would normally have to pay good money for.mahjongg wrote:Only a competitor who wants to destroy the PI would come up with such unrealistic borderline trolling nonsense. It reads like a child's Santa Claus wishlist, no reality involved, "I want a jumbo jet, a real one....".
Please keep it sane!
No one making a serious suggestion is expecting the Foundation to deliver everything they ask for just because they asked for it, but it won't be "insane" if the Foundation deliver it or go some way towards it. Just because something may be unrealistic or unlikely doesn't mean it's insane.
There is plenty the Pi has delivered which others have said was impossible and would never be had. The Foundation is perfectly capable of deciding what is actually insane or should be discounted; I don't really see the need to self-limit or police people's wish lists no matter how imaginative or wild they may be. Just let people express their "insane" ideas if they want to. It does no harm, and no one is forced to read these threads.
I personally think there should be a separate "wish list" forum so people can shout at the moon, express their desires, and those who don't like that can simply ignore it. That should keep everyone happy.