God
Posts: 25
Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2012 11:39 am

Delivery Woes

Wed Aug 22, 2012 7:05 am

The delivery date on my pibow has just gone back yet again so I have cancelled and ordered one of these instead: http://www.bit.ly/NEBKQU. I’ll let you know if it is any good when it arrives.

God
Posts: 25
Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2012 11:39 am

Re: Delivery Woes

Sat Aug 25, 2012 9:42 am

Well, the case arrived three days later (Pibow take note!) and I am very pleased, the quality is excellent. The acrylic panels were protected both sides so all were squeaky clean upon peeling.

Easy-peasy to put together, all the apertures are a sensible size and line up perfectly, it’s a doddle to take it apart if you want to plug anything extra on to the board. The lid has a rather fetching Raspberry Pi logo cut out. There are no legends anywhere else on the box, which I am rather pleased about. I think most of us can tell a USB slot from a power connector!

So, good quality, cheap and delivered quickly what more do you need!
Attachments
picase1.jpg
picase1.jpg (48.16 KiB) Viewed 2262 times
picase2.jpg
picase2.jpg (47.94 KiB) Viewed 2262 times
picase3.jpg
picase3.jpg (53.95 KiB) Viewed 2262 times

ripping
Posts: 32
Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2012 10:55 am
Location: New Zealand

Re: Delivery Woes

Sun Aug 26, 2012 2:45 am

I have to throw my 2 cents in here. I now have 5 raspi's, and bought 5 different cases for them.
1st one to arrive was the Adafruit case like yours. And in later days and weeks I got a Lego, Built-to-spec, Pibow and modmypi cases.
The pricing of all these cases was around 30-35 NZ dollars landed, close enough for the price differences to be negligible.
The quickest to be delivered was the adafruit, then built-to-spec, then Lego, Pibow and slowest was modmypi.
The best case would have to be the pibow, the fit of the raspi is bang-on, and nothing moves a millimetre once assembled. Its small, solid and looks the part too.

Built-to-spec (BTS) has the next best case - its a close thing between it and the pibow. The BTS has been well designed, I like the 'industrial' look.. but the case does move a little when you twist it... and the raspi isn't held firmly inside, there is about 1mm of up/down movement on the SD card end.

Next, in my opinion would be the modmypi case. Its a very simple clip together affair made of thin light (cheap?) plastic. There is more movement of the raspi, but I used a few bits of blutack to keep in under control. It looks tidy enough, although the price is about twice what I would expect to pay for such a unit - its 2 parts, and manufactured using injection moulding (I would assume) or similar.
Compare the complication of this to the BTS case that has maybe 20 separate parts? for essentially the same landed price. Manufactured cost of the modmypi should well under $1 (60p) - in a perfect world with MASS production etc. (Delivery was also the slowest - by some margin).

Next best case is the LEGO from The Daily Brick. Made of perhaps 60 lego pieces it's...... well it's LEGO - quality assured. But the inventory of LEGO blocks is obviously limited and this case suffers from that. Lateral movement is held in check as the blocks sit snugly up to the sides of the raspi board, but there is nothing within the LEGO case to prevent up/down movement, and so the board does move around significantly. This can be somewhat remedied with (a big wad of) blutack again... but it would be nice to have a better method to prevent the movement.

In a distant last comes the Adafruit case. It is a simple enough design of six separate pieces that are held together with flexible 'clips' that are incorporated into the side panels. The acrylic is clear, and so it shows off the Raspberry Pi nicely, but the design is a let down. Once assembled there is significant torsional flex in the case when you apply a twisting movement, and the whole unit rattles as the panels are only held together by the flexible tabs (clips) on the side panel. On my particular unit one of these panels was warped (a substantial bow in it), and so this did not help the rigidity.
If you dropped this case it WILL (most likely) fall apart into its individual components and possibly break.
When I dismantled the case to retrieve the Raspberry Pi, one of the tabs (or clips) broke away from the (warped) side panel and so now one end of the case is only held on by one clip. The case was fragile before, now even moreso.
That is my quick and dirty roundup of some of the more popular Raspi cases.
In conclusion, I would recommend a pibow, although it would be nice to have a variation of available colours. 100% clear acrylic would be a good option. But you cannot get a more solid, compact, well fitting case in the small range of cases I have tested.
The BTS case is well worth considering if your like the look (I do), It is solid with little flex, but the Raspi does have a bit too much up/down movement. It seems the builders are considering selling a clear case alongside the current black and purple.
The Built-to-Spec case has been well thought out with only a couple of design niggles.
I do NOT recommend Adafruit unless you MUST have a 100% clear acrylic case. It looks good, but the attraction stops there. Too bad that.

User avatar
adafruit
Posts: 71
Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2012 3:32 pm
Location: NYC, USA
Contact: Website

Re: Delivery Woes

Sun Aug 26, 2012 1:03 pm

hiya!

sounds like you received a case that had some issues (rare, but it happens - there are variations in acrylic thickness from the various vendors once and awhile) drop us a note [email protected] and we'll send you out a replacement right away!

God
Posts: 25
Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2012 11:39 am

Re: Delivery Woes

Mon Aug 27, 2012 9:17 am

Yes it does sound like you had a bad one. Mine is rock solid and there is NO movement of the raspi board.

You mention 6 pieces, there is of course 7 for this case, the inner part of the Ethernet cut-out is shaped to place on the bottom of the board under the Ethernet connector (see top right corner of picture 3), with this in place there is no movement.

At £4 you can't wrong.

ripping
Posts: 32
Joined: Wed Mar 14, 2012 10:55 am
Location: New Zealand

Re: Delivery Woes

Sat Sep 15, 2012 11:15 am

Following my earlier review in this thread, particularly of the Adafruit case, it was suggested that my Adafruit case was substandard in quality, and I was invited to contact Adafruit for a replacement.
The replacement arrived yesterday, and I am pleased to say that the quality of the new case is much much better than the original I received.
The tolerances are much tighter and all acrylic pieces are flat with no warping. The case after assembly has very little movement, and no rattling, and the raspi within is held firmly with no movement in any direction.
My grading of this case has been dramatically improved, and I can now unreservedly recommend it to any potential buyers. Kudos to Adafruit for supplying a replacement case for what was, it seems, an out of spec original - much appreciated. :)

Return to “Other projects”